Pictures affect a viewer emotionally. When a picture shows one particular view of a person, that can lead to a stereotypical idea that may come to represent an entire category of people. These pictures can remain in a person's mind for a lifetime. When pictures are represented time and time again they become part of culture
Communication is easier amongst members of a group who share the same background and use the same language and pictures/symbols. Differences in background can cause trouble in communication
Culture
a set of learned and accepted rules that defines communication for a people- culture evolves-culture tells us how to act
humans form attitudes both within and outside their own culture
Attitudes
attitudes come from experience, interactions with family and friends, education, the media
Dominant Culture
members of a culture who make up majority or who have the economic or political power
members who are not in the dominant culture can be left out or may have difficulty understanding meanings of communication of the dominant culture
Selectivity
the process by which the mind decides what is relevant or insignificant
selectivity can cause instant categorization of people, objects, events
Acculturation
cultural modification of an individual, group, or people by adapting to or borrowing traits from another culture; also : a merging of cultures as a result of prolonged contact
Acculturation is learning aspects of a culture other than one's own - particularly those aspects which will enable the individual to survive in that culture.
Enculturation
the process by which an individual learns the traditional content of a culture and assimilates its practices and values
Enculturation is learning one's own culture
preconceived attitudes and opinions (correct or incorrect) are learned through enculturation
Media Coverage
Do journalists act as independents or a just another member of the herd?
Pack Journalism
Pack journalism is journalism that is practiced by reporters in a group and that is marked by uniformity of news coverage and lack of original thought-the reporting becomes homogeneous, especially when a group of reporters covering the same topic are required to spend large amounts of time together.
Pack journalism occurs because the reporters are often reliant on one another for news tips or are all similarly dependent on a single source for access (which is quite often the very person they are covering). A type of groupthink occurs, as the journalists are constantly aware of what each other are reporting and an informal consensus emerges on what is newsworthy.
The term can also be applied to entire news organizations. For example, pack journalism can occur when a news organization decides to make a particular story the lead story only because other news organizations are doing so. (source: wikipedia)
"Stories that challenge conventional wisdom or present discordant perspectives will receive less attention, and may be buried in a newspaper or appear late in a broadcast. Further, the practice of pack journalism may mean some stories don't get covered at all" (source Newswatch Canada http://www.sfu.ca/cmns/research/newswatch/pcc/pack.html
There is an old saying, "If it bleeds it leads" that applies to the media. Viewers are over exposed to negative events through the media. For example, we turn on the news and the first thing we hear is murder or something bad. We come to believe that we live in a violent area.
Our ideas about what goes on around us is distorted. When we see minority groups portrayed in the media, we more often see the negative story more than the positive ones
The dominant culture in any country controls the media and what is seen. However, with more and more social media, everyday people are able to contribute to what is seen and known. The everyday person now can make a difference in a positive way by sharing truth or a negative way if the substance of what is being shared is inaccurate or fake.
Fake News and the Post-Truth Era- Truth Under Attack
In the aftermath of the 2016 American election, many have written about the rise of fake news and how it may have influenced the election result. We have seen and heard discussions about a Post Truth Era where facts are less important than personal belief. It seems we are experiencing an assault on truth.
The Oxford dictionaries declared "post-truth" the word of the year for 2016.
"After much discussion, debate, and research, the Oxford Dictionaries Word of the Year 2016 is post-truth – an adjective defined as ‘relating to or denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief’.The concept of post-truth has been in existence for the past decade, but Oxford Dictionaries has seen a spike in frequency this year in the context of the EU referendum in the United Kingdom and the presidential election in the United States. It has also become associated with a particular noun, in the phrase post-truth politics. " (See this https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/word-of-the-year/word-of-the-year-2016)
In 2017, readers and viewers of media have seen the US President blast that most mainstream media is "fake news." But is it? If someone disagrees with what you are reporting, does that make it fake? What is the goal of the media in reporting on political leaders? Is it to blindly agree to everything that a leader says or is it to always question what is being presented?
In November of 2016, Canadian journalist for Buzz Feed, Craig Silverman wrote about the phenomenon of fake news. He exposed the fraudulent news that was being spread on sites like facebook. What he specifically was reporting on were stories that were completely made up and how easily they spread and were consumed by those who got their news from sites like facebook. Because the term "fake news" has been exploited by critics of mainstream media, Silverman now says, "I think the term fake news has almost been rendered meaningless at this point."
Kathy English the Public Editor for the Toronto Star writes that the Star now is seeing emails and posts where media critics are hurling the insult at the Toronto Star. In her article "The Facts on 'Fake News"of February 18, 2017, she clarifies what fake news is according to Craig Silverman. To fulfill the requirements of fake, it would have three criteria:
"It has to be 100% false, not a news article or partisan site that gets a few facts wrong"
"It has to be created consciously to be false"
"There has to be an economic motive"
English, ends her article with this,
"Indeed. I have yet to see any validity in any of the "fake news" charges lobbed our way. While it goes without saying, I think it is safe to say, the Toronto Star is not in the business of fake news. While this news organization's work does sometimes fall short of its own journalistic standards, to suggest that the Star would deliberately publish false information is wrong. We don't make stuff up. And that's a fact." (Toronto Star Feb 17, 2017)
What we as citizens are left with is that ultimately it is our responsibility to critically analyze what ever images and stories we see or read. We can't just accept whatever we see as true; we are right to question. On the other hand, we cannot dismiss all legitimate media as lies. Finding truth isn't always easy.
Test your self. Can you distinguish real news vs fake news? Try Factitious to see.
Missing White Women Syndrome
We see obsessive coverage in the US of young white girls/women who are missing or abducted
Natalee Holloway
Jennifer Willbanks The Runaway Bride
It has been dubbed "Missing white woman syndrome" or "missing pretty girl syndrome", by some media critics-where excessive media hype and coverage is devoted to a specific missing white woman or girl, while virtually ignoring missing men, non-white women, or other news stories. (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_white_woman_syndrome)
"A damsel must be white. This requirement is nonnegotiable. It helps if her frame is of dimensions that breathless cable television reporters can credibly describe as "petite," and it also helps if she's the kind of woman who wouldn't really mind being called "petite," a woman with a good deal of princess in her personality. She must be attractive -- also nonnegotiable. Her economic status should be middle class or higher, but an exception can be made in the case of wartime." Eugene Robinson, Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/06/09/AR2005060901729.html
in the US half of the people who go missing are not white, A 2010 academic study, reports that 80% of the news coverage about missing children is about victims who are not black, only 205 of the coverage is about those who are black.See a video detailing the issue https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3YWw5X1rkTQ
In Canada a study published in The Law and Society Association, showed that aboriginal women who go missing in Canada get 27 times less news coverage than white women; and they receive "dispassionate and less-detailed, headlines, articles, and images. ( see Gilchrist, Kristen in sources)
"
According to StatsCan, First Nations women are three and half times more likely to be victims of violence than non-aboriginal women and seven times more likely to be murdered.
It is a shameful record, a product of a complex web of factors: historical, cultural, social, political. “Systemic bias” is how B.C.’s Missing Women Commission of Inquiry chief Wally Oppal described the problem in his 1,448-page report, “Forsaken,” last December. (2013)" (Zerbisias, A "Three Women. Three Deaths", Toronto Star, p.IN1, Jan 19, 2014)
Important Terms:
Prejudice
Refers to a negative or hostile attitude toward another social group, usually racially defined.
Prejudice does NOT automatically lead to discrimination
1. An adverse judgment or opinion formed beforehand or without knowledge or examination of the facts.
2. A preconceived preference or idea.
2. The act or state of holding unreasonable preconceived judgments or convictions.
3. Irrational suspicion or hatred of a particular group, race, or religion.
Discrimination
Refers to an unfavorable action, behavior, outcome, or treatment.
discrimination can occur without prejudice
institutions of society can discriminate (institutional discrimination) even though the agency is not staffed by people with prejudices.
Prejudice and discrimination can take place on the basis of race (physical characteristics like skin color) or ethnicity (traditions, cultural practices, outlooks)
Racism
Racism is prejudice and/or discrimination based on socially significant physical distinctions. What is made socially significant in racial prejudice is the opinion or attitude that automatically assumes superiority and inferiority based on racial differences.
Stereotype
A conventional, formulaic, and oversimplified conception, opinion, or image.
One that is regarded as embodying or conforming to a set image or type.
Prejudice is based on the idea that one group is somehow better than another (mentally, physically, socially, etc.)
Historically dominant cultures have discriminated against various ethnic or other groups- some groups have been able to overcome, most not
Since slavery and slave trade the dominant culture used pictorial stereotypes to maintain power. Europeans who came in contact with Africans, saw a simple society compared to their own and decided that the group was inferior- later they tried to use evolutionary theory to justify racism. Slave traders made money and had an interest to keep the view that the group was less than human- when slaves were brought to new worlds like Europe and North America they were not allowed to keep their own culture. A master-slave mentality made it difficult for blacks to fit in- even after slavery was outlawed discrimination was rampant
Jim Crow was the name of the racial caste system which operated primarily, but not exclusively in southern and border states, between 1877 and the mid-1960s.
Jim Crow was more than a series of rigid anti-Black laws. It was a way of life. Under Jim Crow, African Americans were relegated to the status of second class citizens.
Many Christian ministers and theologians taught that Whites were the Chosen people, Blacks were cursed to be servants, and God supported racial segregation. Craniologists, eugenicists, phrenologists, and Social Darwinists, at every educational level, buttressed the belief that Blacks were innately intellectually and culturally inferior to Whites. To see images of racist memorabilia see The Jim Crow Museum http://www.ferris.edu/htmls/news/jimcrow/
Today we see better views of blacks, but there is an over representation of blacks relating to crime, sports and entertainment. This over representation, reinforces the view that those are the only ways for blacks to be successful .
When advertisers do not respect their market like when the director of Cristal suggested that Hip Hop's attention to the brand might hurt, they can be in for a boycott see Jay-Z
Movies that have actors wearing wigs and heavy body suits portraying black women as loud overweight perpetuate a negative stereotype. (Norbit, Big Mamma's House, Madea's Family Reunion, etc.) These comedies can be quite hurtful.
Members of ethnic and visible minorities are inadequately represented in entertainment and news media. Portrayals of minorities are often stereotypical and demeaning.
In Canada 15 per cent of the population are immigrants and visible minorities. Large urban Canadian centres have 25 to 51 per cent visible minorities (Toronto is over 50%) 70% of TV in Canada comes from US -minorities are seriously under represented
A 2002 study showed minorities made up only 12% of Canadian TV well under the actual number and they are usually not main characters- many are treated as props
A 2002 study of video games showed
most protagonists (86 per cent) were white males
non-white males were portrayed in stereotypical ways
seven out of ten Asian characters as fighters, and eight out of ten African-Americans as sports competitors
nearly nine out of ten African-American females were victims of violence (twice the rate of white females)
79 per cent of African-American males were shown as verbally and physically aggressive, compared to 57 per cent of white males
A 1991 study of Canadian news media by Charles Ungerleider examined objective reporting and the distorted image of ethnic and visible minorities showing reporting is essentially story telling casting people as heroes, villains and victims.
By either ignoring minorities or casting them in the role of villain, journalists unconsciously tell us stories about who is important, who is trustworthy, and who is a troublemaker. As these stories are repeated in the news, they become the "accepted understandings among those to whom alternative interpretations are not evident."
Studies actually show that immigrants are less likely to commit crime and more likely to have higher education
A 1997 study showed that of 54 references to Jamaican in newspapers 54% were about crime
Media position white males as authority figures, while marginalizing the expertise of members of minorities. Approximately 90 per cent of all experts featured in U.S. news stories are white.
Arab stereotyping- depictions of Arabs as terrorists is common on TV and in movies
Aboriginal/Indigenous Stereotyping
Indigenous people have been stereotyped in words and images for hundreds of years. Film, television and comic-book producers have perpetuated these stereotypes over several generations
Stereotype images-Little Big Man); the drunk (Tom Sawyer); the Indian princess (Pocahontas); the loyal sidekick (Tonto)—these images have become ingrained in the consciousness of every North American. Indigenous people are seen as primitive, violent and deceptive or else as passive and full of childlike obedience.
We see romanticized views -an Indian Princess (lured from her tribe to the white world), the Native Warrior (fierce and formidable and a threat to civilized society and white women)and the Noble Savage (Elevated to a sphere of goodness unreachable by those in contaminated white society and usually possessing some spiritual connection to the land. Indigenous people who were seen as savages were even portrayed by other nationalities with darker skin
in1980s and 1990s, CBC improved the portrayals of Aboriginal people in its television dramas. Spirit Bay, The Beachcombers, North of 60 and The Rez using Indigenous actors with real lives in identifiable parts of the country. The shows were successful in having and non indigenous audiences
MASCOTS
Sports teams continue to use indigenous symbols as mascots- Washington Redskins, Chief Wahoo of the Cleveland Indians, The Atlanta Braves and their tomahawk chop- some school in the US are removing their indigenous mascots, but change is slow. Read about sports mascots controversy http://inamerica.blogs.cnn.com/2013/04/04/native-american-mascots-pride-or-prejudice/
Coverage of Indigenous people in the news media centres on political and constitutional issues,land disputes, forest fires, poverty and substance or sexual abuse
Thunderheart the noble savage/ Atlanta Braves Chief Wahoo
Males in most cultures are seen as more important and dominant leading to discrimination against women. We treat female babies differently from boys. Girls are treated with softness while boys are encouraged to be active.
Historically, women have been expected to be fulfilled by marriage where men through career
While women are objectified for sexual appeal, men are valued for intelligence. During the industrial revolution women were allowed to work, but not to vote. Abolitionist activists to free slaves led many to consider rights for women. Women got the vote about 1920. During both wars women worked, after WWII women were pressured to get back in the kitchen- some social progress took place in the 60s, but stereotyping still takes place today.
Television played a large part in 50s family entertainment, and the formation of the perceived correct roles within the family. “Leave it to Beaver”, “The Donna Reed Show”, and “The Adventures of Ozzy and Harriet” popular postwar decades showed the typical North American family.--The mother at home, the father who worked and ruled the family, and happy children who filled the house.
Think of the images you see in advertising. How are women portrayed?
Images of women in advertising often shows only parts of their bodies.
Stereotypes—the femme fatale, the supermom, the sex kitten, the nasty corporate climber.
Television, film and popular magazines depict women and girls who are white, desperately thin, and made up to the max. Twenty years ago, the average model weighed 8 per cent less than the average woman—but today’s models weigh 23 per cent less.80 % of the female characters in video games are scantily clad, 23 % baring breasts or cleavage, 31 per cent exposing thighs, another 31 per cent exposing stomachs or midriffs, and 15 per cent baring their behinds.
Results of Stereotypes;
Unrealistic goals for ideal body shapes, which lead to high rates of anorexia nervosa and bulimia. Women come to believe they are valued based on their body; self-esteem is also based on how their body looks compared to others--Treatment of women as objects, instead of humans
Portrayal of women as passive and not in control of themselves--Women believing that changing their appearance will give them a better life. See also Dying to be Thin http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/thin/
A 1999 report by Children Now organization observes that:
The majority of male characters in media are heterosexual
Male characters are more often associated with the public work, rather than the private sphere of the home, and issues and problems related to work are more significant than personal issues
Non-white male characters are more likely to experience personal problems and are more likely to use physical aggression or violence to solve those problems
Attitudes that link masculinity to power, dominance and control
Typical stereotypes of male characters as the Joker, the Jock, the Strong Silent Type, the Big Shot and the Action Hero, the Buffoon
In advertising men are usually portrayed as virile, muscular and powerful-powerful bodies dominate space in the ads. For women, the focus is on slenderness, dieting, and attaining a feminine ideal; women are always presented as not just thin, but also weak and vulnerable.
In advertising men are usually portrayed in an activity while women simply look into the camera
According to Cele Otnes, an Illinois professor, “A lot of ads directed at males are still dominated by ‘The Player,’ ‘The Beer Drinker’ or ‘The Buddy,’ ” she said. “But those stereotypes don’t actually fit the vast majority of males. Advertisers and marketers need to broaden the spectrum, and create campaigns centered on more of the actual roles that men play – ‘The Dad,’ ‘The Husband’ and ‘The Handyman.’ Those types of ads weren’t easy to find at the time we were doing our research.” (Source:http://news.illinois.edu/news/12/0801advertisingmasculinity_CeleOtnes.html )
In recent years the stereotype of the dumb bumbling father has played out in commercials and in TV shows, but men are speaking out see the 2012 article No more dumb old dad: Changing the bumbling father stereotype http://www.cnn.com/2012/06/12/living/dumb-dad-stereotype
Cruising 1980 A serial killer brutally slays and dismembers several gay men in New York's S&M and leather districts.
ACT Poster 2010
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Stereotypes
LGBT community is most diverse
History in Media
The LGBT community have often been negatively stereotyped by consigning them to the margins of entertainment media, playing either "colourful" and "flamboyant" characters or dangerous psychopaths.
The Celluloid Closet by Vito Russo analyzes the representation of gays and lesbians in Hollywood films from the 1890s to the 1980s, and demonstrates a history of homophobia. He reports Hollywood’s portrayal of lesbians and gay men has often been cruel and homophobic. Gay and lesbian characters have been defined by their sexual orientation, and lacked any complex character development. In Hollywood movies between 1890s and1930s, homosexuality was often presented as an object of ridicule and laughter.
1930s to the 1950s, religious and women’s groups criticized Hollywood films for contributing to immorality. As a result, the industry introduced a self-censorship code that affected the portrayal of homosexuality. Films could not feature overtly homosexual characters—so homosexuality was suggested through a character’s mannerisms and behaviour.
This strict code was loosened in the 1960s and 1970s
Gays and lesbians were becoming more visible and vocal in public life, but their representation in films was becoming even more homophobic.
Since the 1990s, Hollywood has improved its portrayal of gay and lesbian characters. Popularity of TV shows such as Will & Grace, La vie, la vie… or Queer Eye for the Straight Guy illustrate networks are willing to feature gay characters, as long as the shows draw high ratings, and profits for advertisers.
Will & Grace showed two openly gay male characters but not much was seen about gay relationships or romance. The two gay characters are friends, not lovers, and are rarely shown in romantic situations. The primary relationship for both gay men is with the heterosexual female characters.
Hollywood has developed a new genre: the gay/straight romance--My Best Friend’s Wedding, The Object of My Affection, and The Next Best Thing all portray a gay man and straight woman as the "perfect couple"
The success of Queer as Folk and the L Word is used as evidence that these shows can be popular and profitable. However, some advertisers still are cautious about sponsoring the programming.
A 1998 study analyzed 50 years of coverage of gay and lesbian issues in Time and Newsweek, finding that news media reinforce prejudice and discrimination against gays and lesbians with gays and lesbians often linked to deviant/criminal behaviour; and that the media often reprint offensive and homophobic comments. which may reinforce an incorrect assumption that gays and lesbians are inferior.
HIV/AIDS
Many say news coverage of HIV/AIDS has drawn on negative stereotypes about gays and lesbians
The media are making progress in its depiction LGBT with the active courting of gay and lesbian consumers through gay-positive advertising and marketing campaigns.
In 1983 the AIDS Committee of Toronto (ACT) was born. Throughout the years they have used graphics, sex and humour to save lives by informing the public about the issues in a way that all could understand. Read a story about the imagery and history "How graphics, sex and humour saved lives"and see more on their campaigns ACT Campaigns
Recent CHANGE
According to Stuart Elliot of the New York Times, "Recently, however, L.G.B.T. ads have been getting broader exposure. While targeted media and events remain part of the game plan, they are also running in mainstream media that, in addition to general cable channels, include magazines like Family Circle, newspapers like The New York Times and social media like Facebook, Tumblr, Twitter and YouTube." Mainstream companies that are leading the way with LGBT ads are Expedia, Amazon, Anheiser Busch, General Mills, Google, American Airlines, Kraft, Microsoft, Mastercard. One of the main reasons for this change is the younger generation who have grown up in more diverse times. In spite of these attempts to have more equality in representation of LGBT, those marketers who have created social media campaigns do find that their campaigns have vocal detractors who post their opposition. (NYTimes, June 25, 2013)
As Irshad Manji, a Toronto-based journalist, has said, "We need more than different faces and different experiences to combat racism. We need people - people of all backgrounds - with an anti-racist understanding and a commitment to being vocal about it."